Website Builder Awards

I Built a Forum Website: What Worked, What Didn’t, and What I’d Do Again

Written by

in

You know what? Building a forum sounds simple. Posts, replies, maybe a few badges. But it’s not that neat. I’ve done it twice, and both times taught me new things. Here’s my honest take, with real numbers, real tools, and a few facepalm moments.

Quick map of where we’re going

  • Why I wanted a forum
  • What I built, and with what
  • The build, step by step
  • Real problems I hit (and how I fixed them)
  • What went great
  • Costs, time, and traffic
  • Tips I wish I had on day one

Why a forum at all?

I run a tiny hobby group for beginner bike repair. We tried a Facebook group first. It got loud, messy, and hard to search. Good posts fell off the feed in a day. People kept asking the same tire question. I needed threads. I needed tags. I needed calm.

So I made a forum. Twice.

  • First try: WordPress with bbPress. Felt comfy. Looked like the blog we already had.
  • Second try: Discourse on its own server. Felt modern. Worked better on phones.

I kept both for a while, then moved all chatter to Discourse. I still use WordPress for the front page and guides.

What I used (both times)

  • WordPress 6.x with bbPress and a few helpers: Yoast, WP Mail SMTP, Akismet.
  • Discourse 3.x on a small server at DigitalOcean (2 GB RAM, 1 vCPU, $12/month plan).
  • Mailgun for email (started free, later $35/month once volume grew).
  • Cloudflare (free) for DNS and a little speed.
  • Backups to a cheap S3 bucket, nightly.
  • A clean theme and our own logo. Nothing fancy.

Honestly, I thought bbPress would be enough. And it was… for a bit.

Build #1: WordPress + bbPress (fast, but fussy later)

I spun this up in one rainy weekend. It was quick because I knew WordPress.

  • I installed bbPress, set up a few forums: “Tires,” “Brakes,” and “Shop Talk.”
  • I used WP Mail SMTP with Mailgun. Email worked right away. That felt nice.
  • Akismet stopped most spam. Not all, but most.

What worked:

  • Fast to launch.
  • Easy for our older members. It looked like a normal site.
  • Good for short threads.

What bugged me:

  • Search felt weak once we hit 100+ threads.
  • No real trust system. New users could post junk faster than I could catch it.
  • Mobile view was okay, not great. People text on the go. They wanted better.

By month two, we hit around 200 members and maybe 15 posts per day. Threads got tangled. I started to feel tired. That’s when I moved to Discourse.

Build #2: Discourse (took longer, worth it)

I set up Discourse on a 2 GB DigitalOcean droplet. It used Docker, Postgres, and Redis. That sounds heavy, but the install script held my hand. I pointed DNS at the server with Cloudflare, then set Mailgun for SMTP. After that, it just… ran.

Steps I took:

  • Pointed forum.mysite.com to the server with an A record in Cloudflare.
  • Ran the Discourse installer. Entered my domain and email settings.
  • Set “force HTTPS” in settings. No mixed content headaches after that.
  • Turned on tags and categories. This made threads easy to find.
  • Enabled the Akismet plugin. That reduced spam by a lot.
  • Added “Login with Google.” People like one-click login.
  • Made daily backups to S3. I sleep better with backups.

A small digression: I tried dark mode with a custom theme at first. It looked cool. It also hid some buttons for new folks. I switched back to the default with minor color tweaks. Clarity over cute.

Real problems I hit (and how I fixed them)

Let me explain. Stuff went wrong. That’s normal.

  • Emails stuck in “queued”: My Mailgun domain wasn’t fully verified. I missed a DNS TXT record. Once I added it, welcome emails flowed.
  • Big images felt slow: Our crew loves posting tire photos. I set a size limit and turned on image optimization. I also nudged folks to upload from Wi-Fi. Simple, but it helped.
  • Spam bursts at 2 a.m.: I set new users to trust level 0 with post limits. Akismet caught most. Mods handled the rest in the morning. No panic.
  • Old bbPress posts didn’t match new tags: I did a light import and then hand-tagged the top 50 threads. Yes, it took an hour. Yes, it was worth it. Search got way better.
  • A member got locked out: They used a work email with strict filters. I added a “Resend email” button to the header and showed the login link more clearly. Problem solved.

What went great

This part made me smile.

  • Mobile is smooth: 60% of our users are on phones. Discourse felt fast. Replies stacked cleanly.
  • Trust levels: The forum learned who was helpful. It let them edit titles, flag spam, and guide newbies without me yelling across the room.
  • Search that actually finds things: If I type “700×32 tire pinch,” I get the right thread, not ten random posts.
  • Tag + category mix: “Tires” + “Commuting” tells a story. People find their tribe.
  • Backups and updates: One click for updates. Nightly backups. I test changes on a staging droplet first. No sweaty palms.

Traffic, time, and cost

Real numbers from my notebook:

  • Build time: bbPress in 1 weekend; Discourse in 1 long day plus tweaks over a week.
  • Members: 500 by month three; 1,200 by month nine.
  • Posts: About 30 per day early on; now around 75 on busy weeks.
  • Costs per month:
    • DigitalOcean: $12
    • Mailgun: $0 at first, then about $19 to $35 as it grew
    • S3 backups: around $2
    • Cloudflare: $0 (free plan)
  • My time: 1 to 2 hours a week for mod work and small updates. On launch weeks, more like 5.

The vibe and the rules (soft stuff matters)

Forums live or die on tone. We wrote a tiny guide: “Be kind. Show your fix. Credit your source.” It fit on one page. I pinned it. When someone got snippy, I sent a friendly note, not a hammer. The room stayed warm. People stuck around.

We also gave small badges for first repairs, good photos, and clear steps. Sounds cheesy, but folks loved it.

Little things that felt big

  • Weekly digest emails brought quiet members back.
  • A “Welcome thread” did more than any ad.
  • A “Solved” tag saved time. It also made old posts useful.
  • We added seasonal themes. Winter rides, spring tune-ups. It kept things fresh.
  • Planning ahead for spin-off resources? Reading about building five real directory sites gave me ideas on structure and navigation.

When bbPress is enough vs when to go Discourse

  • Use bbPress if you’re already deep in WordPress, want a quick start, and expect light chatter.
  • Go Discourse if you expect fast growth, want strong mobile, and care about search and trust tools.

I know, I kind of said both. That’s true. Tools are like tires—you pick for the road you’re on. For a deeper data-driven comparison, I checked out SimilarTech’s bbPress vs Discourse stats, which highlights usage patterns across the web. If you’re more of a checklist person, the table on SourceForge’s Discourse vs bbPress feature grid is also handy.

For a broader perspective on how various platforms stack up, take a look at the independent breakdown on WebsiteBuilderAwards—it gave me solid context before I committed to Discourse. They also cover niche cases, like how I built three classified ads sites and what actually worked, which helped me think through monetization. If you want the shorter version, the author also recapped it under I built 3 classifieds sites which dives straight into tech choices.

While most of our conversations revolve around bike repair, I’ve learned that forums serving more adult-oriented niches have their own tooling and safety needs. A colleague who moderates a relationship community pointed me to an in-depth comparison of hookup services—especially useful if your members often ask “which app is best for X?” Check out this breakdown of ebony-focused dating apps at Fuck Black Girls – Best Apps for Ebony Hookups. The article

More posts